Skip to content

Please, No More Generals!

July 5, 2020

The New York Times published an “Opinion” essay on December 7, 2020 opposing the nomination of a retired Army general, Lloyd Austin, for secretary of defense.

There are good reasons to affirm civilian control of DOD that, apparently, President Biden has ignored in order to “color” his Administration in black, brown and yellow hues.

The National Security Act of 1947 that created the U.S Department of Defense made it a requirement that only civilians could lead that Department. Service agencies were also required to be led by civilians.

Gradually, however, the appointment of former Generals and Admirals came into prominence.  Here is a list.

Ronald Reagan:       Gen. Al Haig, Secretary of State

                                    Gen. Colin Powell, National Security Council

Bush 41                     Gen. Brent Scowcroft, National Security Advisor

Bush 43:                    Gen. Colin Powell, Secretary of State

Barack Obama:        Gen. Eric Shinseki, Veterans Affairs

The damn burst with the election of President Donald Trump who did not serve in the U.S. military but has demonstrated a loyalty to, and fondness for, former Generals  and Admirals.  Some point to President Trump’s education at New York Military Academy, where his parents sent him when they felt he needed to acquire discipline. In fact, Donald Trump is Dyslexic and needed therapy to improve his impaired ability to read.

Donald Trump’s affection for high rank military can be explained as an attitude acquired as a 17-year old Cadet at New York Military Academy that a former graduate described to me as a place for “Bullies from the Bronx.” This list of Trump Administration appointees can be traced to that experience.

Gen. James N. Mattis, Secretary of Defense

Gen. Michael T. Flynn, first National Security Advisor

Gen. H.R. McMastersecond National Security Advisor

Gen. John F. Kelly, Homeland Security and Chief of Staff

Brig. General, Mitchell Zais, Deputy Secretary of Education 

Rear Admiral Eric C. Jones, Military Advisor to the  Secretary of Homeland Security

Adm. Harry Harris, Ambassador to South Korea

Gen. Gustave Perna, CEO, Operation “Warp Speed”

Add to this list, Mike Pompeo, a West Point graduate who finished first in his graduating class, and attained the rank of Captain in ten years of military service from 1986-1991.

Due to his Dyslexia, Donald Trump doesn’t read books, nor, apparently, daily Intelligence Reports. This is important because our traditional Constitutional order is challenged when acts of terror, domestic and foreign, call for a military response. Bush 43 empowered a “war faction” in the President’s Party, typified by the appointment Michael Gerson.

President Trump appointed John Bolton as National Security Advisor. That appointment and the many career military in the Trump Administration placed President Trump’s desire to avoid war in the company of many top appointees trained to fight wars.

It’s clear, President Trump lacked appreciation of the limits that the Constitution of the United States places on the Executive Branch. Lacking in the governance of his Office as Commander and Chief is any understanding of the long history of civilian control of the American government that began after our War of Independence in resistance to a standing Army.

Americans who had fought the British Army were in no mood to fight an American Army.

When President Trump sent in troops to deter domestic protests and used the military salute at ceremonies at Arlington National Cemetery, appointed dozens of Generals and Admirals to top civilian posts and expresses unlimited confidence in the powers of “the State,” we must fear that President Trump may refuse to leave office.

And what about the Republican Party “brand” of limited government?

After George W. Bush and Donal Trump, the Grand Old Party is so battered and defenseless that it can no longer attract leaders able and willing to deter the United States of America from domination by the Administrative State.

No comments yet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: